{
  "artifact": "cleartrace_scorecard_edition",
  "edition": 1,
  "published": "2026-07-04",
  "generated_at": 1783137884.145174,
  "chain": "ethereum",
  "metric": "aggregator_leaderboard",
  "quote_preliminary": false,
  "note": "Execution cost + revert rate are on-chain over ALL trades (Component A, high volume). Quote accuracy is a forward-captured fork-sim sample (Component B) \u2014 see quote_confidence. Rows with quote_sampled=false are on-chain-only (we report their execution + revert numbers but don't yet sample their quotes). is_baseline=true marks a VENUE default (Uniswap): its execution cost is the direct-DEX median \u2014 the default aggregators are compared against, not routed execution. rfq_share_1m = % of $1M flow routed via off-chain RFQ (sampler); its reliability is onchain_revert_rate_pct.",
  "rows": [
    {
      "source": "bitget_dex_aggregator",
      "dune_project": "bitget_dex_aggregator",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 2.32,
      "onchain_toxicity": 2.3,
      "onchain_trades": 6488,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.29,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 52904
    },
    {
      "source": "oneinch",
      "dune_project": "1inch",
      "quote_sampled": true,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0,
      "quote_confidence": "rated",
      "quote_realized_samples": 968,
      "rfq_share": 0.0,
      "rfq_share_1m": 0.0,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 7.02,
      "onchain_toxicity": 7.0,
      "onchain_trades": 14330,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 2.16,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 99483
    },
    {
      "source": "bebop",
      "dune_project": "bebop",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 9.73,
      "onchain_toxicity": 9.7,
      "onchain_trades": 1419,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 8.05,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 106185
    },
    {
      "source": "uniswap",
      "dune_project": "uniswap",
      "quote_sampled": true,
      "is_baseline": true,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0,
      "quote_confidence": "rated",
      "quote_realized_samples": 1001,
      "rfq_share": 0.0,
      "rfq_share_1m": 0.0,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 10.54,
      "onchain_toxicity": 10.5,
      "onchain_trades": 286686,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.61,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 10774
    },
    {
      "source": "kyberswap",
      "dune_project": "kyberswap",
      "quote_sampled": true,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": 2.87,
      "quote_confidence": "rated",
      "quote_realized_samples": 920,
      "rfq_share": 0.208,
      "rfq_share_1m": 0.86,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 12.08,
      "onchain_toxicity": 12.1,
      "onchain_trades": 15212,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 4.28,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 137934
    },
    {
      "source": "odos",
      "dune_project": "odos",
      "quote_sampled": true,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0,
      "quote_confidence": "rated",
      "quote_realized_samples": 831,
      "rfq_share": 0.0,
      "rfq_share_1m": 0.0,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 14.3,
      "onchain_toxicity": 14.3,
      "onchain_trades": 2800,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 23.78,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 2090
    },
    {
      "source": "cow_protocol",
      "dune_project": "cow_protocol",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 15.72,
      "onchain_toxicity": 15.7,
      "onchain_trades": 10492,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.11,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 47118
    },
    {
      "source": "openocean",
      "dune_project": "openocean",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 16.42,
      "onchain_toxicity": 16.4,
      "onchain_trades": 4031,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 10.95,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 13892
    },
    {
      "source": "1inch-LOP",
      "dune_project": "1inch-LOP",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 27.67,
      "onchain_toxicity": 27.7,
      "onchain_trades": 1173,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.84,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 30111
    },
    {
      "source": "sushiswap",
      "dune_project": "sushiswap",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 34.9,
      "onchain_toxicity": 34.9,
      "onchain_trades": 3135,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 4.8,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 26313
    },
    {
      "source": "paraswap",
      "dune_project": "velora",
      "quote_sampled": true,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": 1.0,
      "quote_confidence": "rated",
      "quote_realized_samples": 977,
      "rfq_share": 0.0,
      "rfq_share_1m": 0.0,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 43.01,
      "onchain_toxicity": 43.0,
      "onchain_trades": 3740,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 3.83,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 25572
    },
    {
      "source": "tokenlon",
      "dune_project": "tokenlon",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": 64.48,
      "onchain_toxicity": 64.5,
      "onchain_trades": 2339,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.04,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 2789
    },
    {
      "source": "DODO X",
      "dune_project": "DODO X",
      "quote_sampled": false,
      "is_baseline": false,
      "quote_median_gap_bps": null,
      "quote_confidence": "none",
      "quote_realized_samples": 0,
      "rfq_share": null,
      "rfq_share_1m": null,
      "onchain_slippage_bps": null,
      "onchain_toxicity": null,
      "onchain_trades": null,
      "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.15,
      "onchain_routing_txs": 6886
    }
  ],
  "execution_by_frontend": [
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap: UniversalRouter",
      "confidence": "high",
      "total_trades": 1618,
      "median_slippage_bps": 2.54,
      "execution_quality_score": 97.5
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "aggregator_api_direct",
      "originating_frontend": null,
      "confidence": "medium",
      "total_trades": 1127,
      "median_slippage_bps": 2.83,
      "execution_quality_score": 97.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "total_trades": 869,
      "median_slippage_bps": 5.84,
      "execution_quality_score": 94.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "wallet_embedded",
      "originating_frontend": "metamask: MetaSwap",
      "confidence": "high",
      "total_trades": 5077,
      "median_slippage_bps": 6.02,
      "execution_quality_score": 94.0
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 3468,
      "median_slippage_bps": 8.08,
      "execution_quality_score": 91.9
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "unattributed",
      "originating_frontend": null,
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 217738,
      "median_slippage_bps": 8.5,
      "execution_quality_score": 91.5
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "unattributed",
      "originating_frontend": null,
      "confidence": "none",
      "total_trades": 188575,
      "median_slippage_bps": 12.83,
      "execution_quality_score": 87.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter02",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 1812,
      "median_slippage_bps": 25.8,
      "execution_quality_score": 74.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap: UniversalRouter",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 1236,
      "median_slippage_bps": 31.67,
      "execution_quality_score": 68.3
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "sushiswap: RouteProcessor11",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "total_trades": 474,
      "median_slippage_bps": 41.91,
      "execution_quality_score": 58.1
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "paraswap_v6: AugustusFeeVault",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "total_trades": 590,
      "median_slippage_bps": 43.77,
      "execution_quality_score": 56.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "aggregator_api_direct",
      "originating_frontend": "paraswap: AugustusV6_2",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "total_trades": 562,
      "median_slippage_bps": 46.62,
      "execution_quality_score": 53.4
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "pancakeswap_v3: SwapRouter",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 352,
      "median_slippage_bps": 47.77,
      "execution_quality_score": 52.2
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v2: UniswapV2Factory",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 1383,
      "median_slippage_bps": 74.04,
      "execution_quality_score": 26.0
    },
    {
      "blockchain": "ethereum",
      "bucket": "named_frontend",
      "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v2: Router02",
      "confidence": "low",
      "total_trades": 1383,
      "median_slippage_bps": 74.24,
      "execution_quality_score": 25.8
    }
  ]
}