{ "artifact": "cleartrace_scorecard_edition", "edition": 3, "published": "2026-09-08", "generated_at": 1788886999.781819, "onchain_as_of": "2026-09-08T16:41:27.169857+00:00", "onchain_window_days": 7, "onchain_slippage_as_of": "2026-09-08T16:41:21+00:00", "onchain_as_of_covers": [ "revert_rates", "execution_slippage" ], "chain": "ethereum", "metric": "aggregator_leaderboard", "quote_preliminary": false, "note": "Execution cost + revert rate are on-chain over ALL trades (Component A, high volume). Quote accuracy is a forward-captured fork-sim sample (Component B). See quote_confidence. Rows with quote_sampled=false are on-chain-only (we report their execution + revert numbers but don't yet sample their quotes). is_baseline=true marks a VENUE default (Uniswap): its execution cost is the direct-DEX median, the default that aggregators are compared against, not routed execution. onchain_user_revert_rate_pct is the revert rate over only senders classified as genuine users (methodology v6). On rows flagged revert_known_residual (headline dominated by documented bot spam) it is the rate users actually experience. execution_model is router | batch_auction | intent | unclassified, and revert_comparable=true ONLY for routers, the model where the user submits the swap, so a failed swap is a reverted user transaction we can count. On a batch auction (CoW) or an intent venue (1inch Fusion) a solver/resolver submits, so an unfilled order never becomes a transaction: the on-chain revert rate is structurally near zero and is NOT a reliability signal. Do not rank revert rates across execution models.", "rows": [ { "source": "bitget_dex_aggregator", "dune_project": "bitget_dex_aggregator", "quote_sampled": false, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": null, "quote_confidence": "none", "quote_realized_samples": 0, "onchain_slippage_bps": 4.14, "onchain_toxicity": 4.1, "onchain_trades": 6730, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.72, "onchain_routing_txs": 35895, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.69, "onchain_user_txs": 34194, "onchain_reverted_txs": 619, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 237, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "oneinch", "dune_project": "1inch", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 12021, "onchain_slippage_bps": 7.45, "onchain_toxicity": 7.5, "onchain_trades": 21302, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.16, "onchain_routing_txs": 126629, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.23, "onchain_user_txs": 122398, "onchain_reverted_txs": 1465, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 280, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "openocean", "dune_project": "openocean", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 10.23, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 6983, "onchain_slippage_bps": 9.34, "onchain_toxicity": 9.3, "onchain_trades": 1120, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 2.16, "onchain_routing_txs": 8410, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.32, "onchain_user_txs": 7715, "onchain_reverted_txs": 182, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 25, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "cow_protocol", "dune_project": "cow_protocol", "quote_sampled": false, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": null, "quote_confidence": "none", "quote_realized_samples": 0, "onchain_slippage_bps": 9.66, "onchain_toxicity": 9.7, "onchain_trades": 13463, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.22, "onchain_routing_txs": 27258, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.18, "onchain_user_txs": 27177, "onchain_reverted_txs": 60, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 48, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "batch_auction", "revert_comparable": false }, { "source": "bebop", "dune_project": "bebop", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 8512, "onchain_slippage_bps": 10.74, "onchain_toxicity": 10.7, "onchain_trades": 3493, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 2.61, "onchain_routing_txs": 18952, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 1.32, "onchain_user_txs": 18410, "onchain_reverted_txs": 495, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 243, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "unclassified", "revert_comparable": false }, { "source": "uniswap", "dune_project": "uniswap", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": true, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 11503, "onchain_slippage_bps": 10.93, "onchain_toxicity": 10.9, "onchain_trades": 347324, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 2.61, "onchain_routing_txs": 145635, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 1.04, "onchain_user_txs": 134234, "onchain_reverted_txs": 3804, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 1400, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "kyberswap", "dune_project": "kyberswap", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.26, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 11560, "onchain_slippage_bps": 11.48, "onchain_toxicity": 11.5, "onchain_trades": 21085, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.26, "onchain_routing_txs": 294054, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.62, "onchain_user_txs": 285756, "onchain_reverted_txs": 3719, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 1780, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "1inch-LOP", "dune_project": "1inch-LOP", "quote_sampled": false, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": null, "quote_confidence": "none", "quote_realized_samples": 0, "onchain_slippage_bps": 11.71, "onchain_toxicity": 11.7, "onchain_trades": 1240, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.48, "onchain_routing_txs": 47754, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.24, "onchain_user_txs": 47028, "onchain_reverted_txs": 228, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 113, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "intent", "revert_comparable": false }, { "source": "sushi", "dune_project": "sushiswap", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 11081, "onchain_slippage_bps": 11.8, "onchain_toxicity": 11.8, "onchain_trades": 1280, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.96, "onchain_routing_txs": 53299, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.3, "onchain_user_txs": 51719, "onchain_reverted_txs": 511, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 156, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "paraswap", "dune_project": "velora", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 1.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 11585, "onchain_slippage_bps": 19.52, "onchain_toxicity": 19.5, "onchain_trades": 5463, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 1.58, "onchain_routing_txs": 33133, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.34, "onchain_user_txs": 30936, "onchain_reverted_txs": 525, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 104, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "okx", "dune_project": "okx", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 2.5, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 9875, "onchain_slippage_bps": 20.5, "onchain_toxicity": 20.5, "onchain_trades": 3792, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 5.02, "onchain_routing_txs": 39167, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 1.03, "onchain_user_txs": 32934, "onchain_reverted_txs": 1965, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 338, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "tokenlon", "dune_project": "tokenlon", "quote_sampled": false, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": null, "quote_confidence": "none", "quote_realized_samples": 0, "onchain_slippage_bps": 65.73, "onchain_toxicity": 65.7, "onchain_trades": 1964, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.0, "onchain_routing_txs": 2461, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.0, "onchain_user_txs": 2452, "onchain_reverted_txs": 0, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 0, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "unclassified", "revert_comparable": false }, { "source": "odos", "dune_project": "odos", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.0, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 3109, "onchain_slippage_bps": null, "onchain_toxicity": null, "onchain_trades": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": null, "onchain_routing_txs": null, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": null, "onchain_user_txs": null, "onchain_reverted_txs": null, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": null, "revert_known_residual": false, "wound_down": true, "status_note": "Wound down 2026-07-30 \u00b7 data through Jul 2026", "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "lifi", "dune_project": "lifi", "quote_sampled": true, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": 0.71, "quote_confidence": "rated", "quote_realized_samples": 8966, "onchain_slippage_bps": null, "onchain_toxicity": null, "onchain_trades": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": 0.0, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": 3378, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 2.36, "onchain_routing_txs": 45584, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.43, "onchain_user_txs": 42175, "onchain_reverted_txs": 1077, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 180, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "router", "revert_comparable": true }, { "source": "DODO X", "dune_project": "DODO X", "quote_sampled": false, "is_baseline": false, "quote_median_gap_bps": null, "quote_confidence": "none", "quote_realized_samples": 0, "onchain_slippage_bps": null, "onchain_toxicity": null, "onchain_trades": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_bps": null, "onchain_slippage_all_chain_trades": null, "onchain_revert_rate_pct": 0.12, "onchain_routing_txs": 9625, "onchain_user_revert_rate_pct": 0.03, "onchain_user_txs": 9547, "onchain_reverted_txs": 12, "onchain_user_reverted_txs": 3, "revert_known_residual": false, "execution_model": "unclassified", "revert_comparable": false } ], "execution_by_frontend": [ { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter02", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 754, "median_slippage_bps": 1.6, "execution_quality_score": 98.4 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "aggregator_api_direct", "originating_frontend": null, "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 2530, "median_slippage_bps": 3.26, "execution_quality_score": 96.7 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 447, "median_slippage_bps": 4.54, "execution_quality_score": 95.5 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap: UniversalRouter", "confidence": "high", "total_trades": 20315, "median_slippage_bps": 5.41, "execution_quality_score": 94.6 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "wallet_embedded", "originating_frontend": "metamask: MetaBridge", "confidence": "high", "total_trades": 1199, "median_slippage_bps": 5.75, "execution_quality_score": 94.2 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap: UniversalRouter", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 572, "median_slippage_bps": 6.37, "execution_quality_score": 93.6 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "wallet_embedded", "originating_frontend": "metamask: MetaSwap", "confidence": "high", "total_trades": 5976, "median_slippage_bps": 7.32, "execution_quality_score": 92.7 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "unattributed", "originating_frontend": null, "confidence": "low", "total_trades": 234137, "median_slippage_bps": 8.89, "execution_quality_score": 91.1 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "unattributed", "originating_frontend": null, "confidence": "none", "total_trades": 237730, "median_slippage_bps": 11.35, "execution_quality_score": 88.6 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "aggregator_api_direct", "originating_frontend": "paraswap: AugustusV6_2", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 1239, "median_slippage_bps": 12.13, "execution_quality_score": 87.9 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter", "confidence": "low", "total_trades": 1329, "median_slippage_bps": 12.11, "execution_quality_score": 87.9 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap: UniversalRouter", "confidence": "low", "total_trades": 1292, "median_slippage_bps": 16.55, "execution_quality_score": 83.4 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v3: SwapRouter02", "confidence": "low", "total_trades": 2606, "median_slippage_bps": 17.06, "execution_quality_score": 82.9 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "sushiswap: RouteProcessor11", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 891, "median_slippage_bps": 33.29, "execution_quality_score": 66.7 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "uniswap_v2: Router02", "confidence": "low", "total_trades": 5364, "median_slippage_bps": 38.41, "execution_quality_score": 61.6 }, { "blockchain": "ethereum", "bucket": "named_frontend", "originating_frontend": "paraswap_v6: AugustusFeeVault", "confidence": "medium", "total_trades": 777, "median_slippage_bps": 48.06, "execution_quality_score": 51.9 } ] }